I'm not against adding this, I just wonder how to do it "right". Because all those software projects mentioned follow the different convention of having one main container window, and each project is a sub-window of sorts in the main window. When you close a sub window, the application stays open. If however you close the window using the window close controls, it will in fact close the whole applications, sometimes with warnings that you will be closing multiple documents by doing this.
Presently, Inkscape only has window controls, and calls up a new main window for every new file opened. So there are two potential "fixes" for this:
1. Inkscape opens a new document when an edited document is closed - this is easy, but annoying if you don't want a new document. This already happens when ctrl/cmd+w, but getting Inkscape to not close when you use the window close buttons (which isn't great UX imho) may be more of a problem.
2. Inkscape needs to become a sub-window style UI where documents are contained in it, instead of floating around with their own toolsets. Although I typically like this style better, it's a lot more work, and our resources are limited as of now. Often when embarking on a project like this, we are sacrificing time working on other big ticket items. So it comes down to finding someone with loads of time to fix for what I'd consider a relatively minor annoyance.

It's neither lazy, nor arrogant, it's just limited resources, and demands on our dedicated group of awesome developers.

My 2p.
-C



On Mon, Nov 18, 2019 at 12:30 AM Windell H. Oskay <windell@evilmadscientist.com> wrote:


> On Nov 17, 2019, at 4:03 PM, brynn <brynn@frii.com> wrote:
>
> GIMP went to having documents separate from the program with....well, it was the last upgrade that I got anyway.  It drives me crazy.  When I click close, I want close.  I don't want to have to close a few different things to close a program.  I don't think I have any other program (on Windows currently) like that.  Even Libre Office Writer (which has multiple pages) closes with 1 click.

This is a platform-specific difference in expectations. It drives the Mac users equally crazy when a program quits unexpectedly: It is not substantially different from Inkscape hard-crashing when you close a document.

Mac applications almost universally stay open when the last document is closed. (There is normally a "Close" function to close a document, but also a separate "Quit" function to close all open windows and exit the application. This type of behavior is common, but not universal, on Windows as well.) 

The two other applications that you name, GIMP and Libre Office, both handle this correctly (and stay open when you close the last document), as did Inkscape in versions prior to 1.0.

I've opened an issue for it: https://gitlab.com/inkscape/inbox/issues/1193
_______________________________________________
Inkscape Devel mailing list -- inkscape-devel@lists.inkscape.org
To unsubscribe send an email to inkscape-devel-leave@lists.inkscape.org