2015-10-05 13:55 GMT+02:00 Brynn <brynn@...3133...>:
I haven't seen any version of the CoC that I would object to. Although having said that, I think more details are better than less, in this type of document.
If the CoC is too long, it discourages people from actually reading it.
I would really like to see it finalized and finished. There have been a few non-family-friendly images uploaded to the gallery, and it would be nice to be able to quote from the CoC when notifying them why their image was removed.
Or....maybe the CoC is not supposed to cover the images?? Except for "> - Distribution of illegal or pornographic material in Inkscape communities. " I don't see any language about the gallery -- only about how to communicate, and how to behave in a community.
If it's supposed to cover the images, maybe the words "family-friendly" should appear somewhere, as well as some sort of idea what it means. I understand that "family-friendly" has slightly different meanings between the east and the western parts of the world, especially regarding images or art.
If we want to ban "non-family-friendly" images completely, then I can add a section on guidelines for user-submitted content. I thought that this type of art would be allowed but hidden behind a content warning, and not labeling explicit images as such would be penalized.
So we can compare your version to whatever version you worked on -- which version did you edit? It looks like there are 2 or 3 (or more?) versions on this page: https://inkscape.org/en/community/coc/. It looks like you worked on the 1st?
The versions at the bottom of the page are codes from other projects, such as Rust and Django, and the version on top is an amalgamation that was proposed as our CoC. What I wrote is a rather large modification of what was at the top.
The code here is fairly complete and I like the section structure, but is also rather vague for a technical community and contains a lot of stuff that apply only to events where participants are present in person that I think are not relevant to our project. http://citizencodeofconduct.org/
Best regards, Krzysztof