
Hi Inkscapers, I was just talking with a friend while he is working on some diagrams in inkscape, and he wants to be able to have items in multiple groups. (This is a network diagram, so for example it would be nice to have a set of all nodes, to be able to change color and style, but then also put various subnets of nodes into their own groups so they can be transformed as a unit.) Looking into it a bit it seems that this is really a limitation of the way svg handles groups, and since both groups and layers in inkscape are implemented with svg groups I guess it's not possible to use a set oriented approach like this? Any ideas why groups are limited in this way within the svg spec? I can imagine a number of situations in which it would be nice to change style attributes or script or transform on different sets of potentially overlapping objects. Any thoughts on this?
-Jeff

On 6/28/07, Jeff Rose <jeff@...1764...> wrote:
Hi Inkscapers, I was just talking with a friend while he is working on some diagrams in inkscape, and he wants to be able to have items in multiple groups.
Long ago I've written a detailed RFE on this:
http://sourceforge.net/tracker/index.php?func=detail&aid=971544&grou...
So, all that is needed is an enthusiastic developer to program this (simple!) feature :)
Any ideas why groups are limited in this way within the svg spec?
Because SVG is XML, and XML is fundamentally non-overlapping. XML would have never reached the level of ubiquity it now enjoys if it wasn't simple and straightforward like that.
participants (2)
-
bulia byak
-
Jeff Rose