On Wed, 2015-02-11 at 17:17 -0800, Bryce Harrington wrote:
On Wed, Feb 11, 2015 at 07:07:45PM -0500, Tony Sebro wrote:
On 02/11/2015 06:57 PM, Bryce Harrington wrote:
On Wed, Feb 11, 2015 at 05:31:08PM -0500, Tony Sebro wrote:
The goal here is to prevent a corporation from taking control over the project by hiring PLC members and/or otherwise dominating the PLC, so that they could exploit Conservancy's nonprofit structure to handle activities that really should fall under their for-profit structure. It's not my intent to make this section onerous; we can discuss ways to make it fit Inkscape's community standards.
For much of the life of the project, Ted, Tim, and I all worked for Canonical, and served on the board as the project founders. Canonical could have cared less about Inkscape and had zero influence on board matters.
Presently Jon and I both work for Samsung, having both just recently joined there. Samsung cares even less about Inkscape than Canonical did. Yet if this provision goes into effect, one or the other of us will have to step down.
Understood. For what it's worth, I've never received anyone complain or insinuate that Inkscape is controlled or influenced by any one corporation. Still: if an issue were to come up in the future, the Inkscape Committee may benefit from avoiding even the optics of influence.
What if we moved from "more than one member employed" to "more than 1/3" or "more than 40%"? Would that give the Committee enough wiggle room going forward?
Probably should speak in fractions of sevenths, otherwise rounding is ambiguous. A hard limit of 3/7th would avoid majority control by any one employer while being flexible with membership.
I'm curious if there isn't a way for a company to specifically declare non-interest in the project. While it would seem extreme, and probably difficult to get at larger companies, it might be a way handle the situation if it does become needed.
That being said, I wish we had a problem with too many companies being interested in Inkscape and fighting over board seats :-P
Ted