bulia byak wrote:
I agree, and this is exactly why our current set is better :) A lot of work went into small meaningful details of the current icons.
I think this is the core of the differing opinion here. You feel the icon will not fulfill it's purpose if it doesn't contain details. I feel the icon will function perfectly well without the details. It's only purpose is to create a visual association and the currently proposed icons from the GIMP set do that suitably.
I think the idea that using the already existing tango icons will cause mass confusion is quite silly. You can debate that the current Paint Bucket is superior than the GIMP Paint Bucket, but at the end of the day it's still a paint bucket - people will get it.
Having said that, I don't think opinions will change. So I'm happy to step away from tangification.